Percentage Based Admission Control gives lower VM restart guarantee?

Those who have configured vSphere HA have all seen that section where it asks if you want to use admission control or not. Of course if you decide you want to use it, and you should want this, then the next question that comes is which one do you want to use? I have always preferred the “Percentage Based Admission Control” policy. For some reason though there are people who think that the percentage based admission control policy rules out large VMs from being restarted or offers a lower guarantee.

The main perception that people have is that the percentages based admission control policy gives lower guarantees of virtual machines being restarted than the “host failures” admission control policy. So let break it down, and I mean BREAK IT DOWN, by using an example.

Example

• 5 hosts
• 200GB of Memory in cluster
• 20GHz of CPU in cluster

If no reservations are set:

Percentage Based will do the following:

1. The Percentage Based policy will take the total amount of resources and subtract the amount of resources reserved for fail-over. If that percentage is for instance 20% than 40GB and 4GHz are subtracted. Which means 160GB and 16GHz are left.
2. The reserved resources for every virtual machine that is powered on is subtracted from what the outcome of 1. was. If no reservation is set memory then memory overhead is subtracted, if the memory overhead is 200MB then 200MB is subtracted from the 160GB that was left resulting in 159,8GB being available. For CPU the default of 32MHz will be used.
3. You can power-on virtual machines until the amount of available resources, according to HA Admission Control, is depleted, yes many VMs in this case.

Host Failures will do the following:

1. The Host Failures policy will calculate the amount of slots. A slot is formed out of two components: memory and cpu. As no reservation is used the default for CPU is used which is 32MHz, with vSphere 5.0 and higher. For memory the largest memory overhead size is used, in this scenario there could be a variety of sizes lets say the smallest is 64MB and the largest 300MB. Now 300MB will be used for the Memory Slot size.
2. Now that the slotsize is known Admission Control will look for the host with the most slots (available resources / slot size) and subtract those slots from the total amount of available slots. (If one host failure is specified). Every time a VM is started a slot is subtracted. If a VM is started with a higher memory reservation we go back to 1 and the math will need to be done again.
3. You can power-on virtual machines until you are out of slots, again… many VMs.

If reservations are set:

Percentage Based will do the following:

1. The Percentage Based policy will take the total amount of resources and subtract the amount of resources reserved for fail-over. If that percentage is for instance 20% than 40GB and 4GHz are subtracted. Which means 160GB and 16GHz are left.
2. The reserved resources for every virtual machine that is powered on is subtracted from what the outcome of 1 was. So if 10GB of memory was reserved, then 10GB is subtracted resulting in 150GB being available.
3. You can power-on virtual machines until available resources are depleted (according to HA Admission Control), but as reservations are used you are “limited” in terms of the amount of VMs you can power-on.

Host Failures will do the following:

1. The Host Failures policy will calculate the amount of slots. A slot is formed out of two components: memory and cpu. As a reservation is used for memory but not for CPU the default for CPU is used which is 32MHz, with vSphere 5.0 and higher. For memory there is a 10GB reservation set. 10GB will be used for the Memory Slot size.
2. Now that the slotsize is known Admission Control will look for the host with the most slots (available resources / slot size) and subtract those slots from the total amount of available slots. (If one host failure is specified). Every time a VM is started a slot is subtracted, yes that is a 10GB memory slot, even if it has for instance a 2GB reservation. If a VM is started with a higher memory reservation we go back to 1 and the math will need to be done again.
3. You can power-on virtual machines until you are out of slots, as a high reservation is set you will be severely limited!

Now you can imagine that “Host Failures” can be on the safe side… If you have 1 reservation set the math will be done with that reservation. This means that a single 10GB reservation will impact how many VMs you can power-on until HA screams that it is out of resources. But at least you are guaranteed you can power them on right? Well yes, but realistically speaking people disable Admission Control at this point as that single 10GB reservation allows you to power on just a couple of VMs. (16 to be precise.)

But but that beats Percentage Based right… because if I have a lot of VMs who says my VM with 10GB reservation can be restarted? First of all, if there are no “unreserved resources” available on any given host to start this virtual machine then vSphere HA will ask vSphere DRS to defragment the cluster.As HA Admission Control had already accepted this virtual machine to begin with, chances are fairly high that DRS can solve the fragmentation.

Also, as the percentage based admission control policy uses reservations AND memory overhead… how many virtual machines do you need to have powered-on before your VM with 10 GB memory reservation is denied to be powered-on? It would mean that none of the hosts has 10GB of unreserved memory available. That is not very likely as that means you would need to power-on hundreds of VMs… Probably way too many for your environment to ever perform properly. So chances of hitting this scenario are limited, extremely small.

Conclusion

Although theoretically possible, it is very unlikely you will end up in situation where one or multiple virtual machines can not be restarted when using the Percentage Based Admission Control policy. Even if you are using reservations on all virtual machines then this is unlikely as the virtual machines have been accepted at some point by HA Admission Control and HA will leverage DRS to defragment resources at that point. Also keep in mind that when using reservations on all virtual machines that Host Failures is not an option as it will skew your numbers as it does the math with “worst case scenario”, a single 10GB reservation can kill your ROI/TCO.

In short: Go Percentage Based!

"Percentage Based Admission Control gives lower VM restart guarantee?" originally appeared on Yellow-Bricks.com. Follow me on twitter - @DuncanYB.